It is Icky and You Suck for Writing It BUT
If you’re interested in Freedom of Speech issues at all, DON’T miss Neil Gaiman’s post on the topic. He does the flat-out best plain-language explanation ever of why defending freedom of speech means defending ALL speech, even speech we find actively icky.
I was complaining the other day about Twilight (as I often do), for being hideously written and revoltingly anti-feminist, and someone asked me, didn’t I wish that crap like that would be taken off the shelves?
And I said NO, I do NOT; rather I wish that people had better taste and didn’t encourage such shitty writing and horrendously stupid depictions of women by buying it — and that the best way to get them to stop buying it was not to pull it off the shelves, but rather to be just as loud and speechy as I can about how badly it sucks. My heated soliloquies to the tune of “Good lord this Twilight crap is pure rubbish” have actually convinced a few people, you know, and those people will not only not buy Twilight; they’ll think a little more about the next art they do buy and whether it’s crappy and/or anti-woman, based on what they now believe because of what I told them about Twlight. If Twlight didn’t exist or wasn’t being sold, that could not have happened. So hell no, I don’t want to get rid of it. I want it to live forever in infamy as an example of what unbelievably sucky writing looks like!
In other words, the answer to bad speech is MORE GOOD SPEECH. This has been proven time and time again, as Maestro Gaiman does such a wonderful job of elucidating. If you hate something, some art or communication that someone else has produced, SPEAK THE HELL UP about it — but don’t make the mistake of trying to get rid of it, or before you know it, someone will be getting rid of something you like.
Free Speech is one of the best things about America that actually stuck around and worked, and the more we defend it, the better we look to everyone and the closer the world comes to true democracy.
That’s right, I said it — If you want to spread democracy, defend the right of speech that you hate to exist. (Then produce twice as much speech about why it sucks. ;)
Posted December 2nd, 2008 in


I'm a polyphasic proselytiser, a provoked pacifist and a pupil philosopher. Any one of my hundred thousand hobbies and interests might be featured here at any time, so keep those eyes peeled. If you've got anything interesting to tell me, you can always get me at puredoxyk*at*puredoxyk*dot*com. Thanks for reading!
23 devoted students of Roshi accepted this page in 0.407 seconds without moving, or saying a word.